is it a lost cause?

topic posted Tue, December 6, 2005 - 11:48 AM by  Beverly
OK, I've stopped trying to correct my friends who use "I" as a direct object ("Mary bought movie tickets for John and I") since it seems to have become accepted as common usage (at least in spoken language).

But then I started hearing direct object forms used as subjects: "Him and John are going to drive up together." At first I thought it was specific to a certain social group, but now I hear it all over. My sweetie has given me permission to correct him when he does it - never in front of anyone else, of course - but I'm starting to think it's a losing battle given how many other people I hear doing it. I've even seen it written that way.

Is it just me? Should I give up and accept that the language is changing? It's like fingernails on a chalkboard every time I hear it. *sigh*
posted by:
Beverly
Seattle
  • Re: is it a lost cause?

    Tue, December 6, 2005 - 5:50 PM
    I've run into this far more often here in Portland than I ever did on the East Coast, where I grew up and lived until I was 24. Could it be a regional issue? (Of course, it just as easily could have been the folks I was hanging out with in New Jersey).

Recent topics in "Grammarians"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Weigh in... your opinion, that is 0 June 5, 2008
a new grammar related tribe Stephanie (... 3 January 24, 2008
Simplified Spelling? 6 November 16, 2007
How does this get punctuated? 25 October 26, 2007